Basket of Bentley's Paw Pantry collagen dog chew rings

Collagen Chews vs. Rawhide: What's the Difference?

If you've shopped for long-lasting dog chews, you've probably seen both rawhide and collagen chews. They can look alike, and both come from cattle, so what's the difference? Here's a quick breakdown to help you choose.

What is rawhide?

Rawhide is made from the dried inner layer of cow or horse hide. It's tough and lasts a long time, which is why it's been popular for decades. The downside: rawhide can be hard for some dogs to digest, and pieces can soften and swell in the stomach. If a dog swallows a large chunk, it can cause choking or a blockage. Some rawhide is also processed and treated before it's shaped into bones and rolls.

What is a collagen chew?

Collagen chews are made from collagen, the protein that gives skin, tendons and joints their structure. They're processed differently from rawhide and are generally considered easier for dogs to digest. Many dog owners choose them as a rawhide-free alternative that still offers plenty of chew time.

Side by side

  • Chew time: Both are long-lasting. Rawhide is often tougher, while collagen chews soften gradually as your dog works on them.
  • Digestibility: Collagen chews are generally easier to digest. Rawhide can be harder on some dogs' stomachs.
  • Protein: Collagen chews are high in protein. Our collagen sticks are about 85% protein and 7% fat.
  • Safety: Any chew can be a choking risk. Supervise your dog, choose the right size, and take the chew away once it's small enough to swallow.

Other rawhide-free chews to try

Collagen isn't the only rawhide-free option. Beef cheek chews are made from natural cheek muscle and are a durable choice for strong chewers. Yak milk chews are a hard, long-lasting cheese chew. Bully sticks are another single-ingredient favorite.

Shop rawhide-free chews

Or browse all of our natural chews.

This article is general information and isn't a substitute for advice from your veterinarian.

Back to blog